
Promise Not to Tell
by Jennifer McMahon
Reading level: Mature Audiences
Paperback: 250 pages
Publisher: William Morrow Paperbacks (April 10, 2007)
ISBN-13: 978-0061143311
Product Dimensions: 8 x 5.4 x .6 inches
Genre: Mystery/Horror
Buy Now at Amazon.com
Buy Now at Amazon.ca
“Promise Not to Tell” by Jennifer McMahon caught me by surprise. I did not expect the book to grab me the way it did. McMahon’s tale of the potato girl and her long-reaching shadow is nothing short of stunning. Here is a look at why I have become a fan of Jennifer McMahon’s writing and why “Promise Not to Tell” is a book I simply couldn’t put down.
The story of the Potato Girl
Kate Cypher, the novel’s lead character, has long been haunted by a figure dubbed The Potato Girl. A childhood friend of Kate’s who met a terrible fate, The Potato Girl’s real name is Del. Since the death of Del, Kate has felt haunted by her actions in the days leading up to her friend’s demise, even though she left town as soon as she could and never looked back.
Decades later, as her mother is battling Alzheimer’s, Kate returns to her home town just in time for a brutal murder, very similar to Del’s. The chain of events that follows is disturbing, stirring and at times, very creepy. Whether Kate expects it or not, her past has come back to haunt her in a very big way.
McMahon’s Storytelling Abilities
I was tremendously surprised by Jennifer McMahon’s storytelling ability. I found myself wanting to check the front cover to see if this story was based on true events; it was not. The book is marketed as pure fiction. The story is masterfully weaved, switching from present to past in a flawless and graceful manner. “Promise Not To Tell” felt more real to me than any other fiction book I’ve read.
A Note on the Ending
Overall, “Promise Not to Tell” is a compelling and gripping novel. The only part I did not love about this amazing read was the ending. While the ending tied up all the loose ends, I felt like it was a bit rushed through the last few chapters.
A Final Word on “Promise Not to Tell”
I could not put this book down. From start to finish, McMahon’s writing kept me interested and the story of the Potato girl took hold of me and never let go. This book sent shivers down my spine and with each turn, captivated me further. If you are looking for a great mystery, give “Promise Not to Tell” a chance. The Potato girl is sure to keep you up at night.
-Amanda Haury

