Reviewed by D. L. Keur
For anyone who wants a lazy Sunday afternoon read, one where you don’t need to worry about sex, religion, politics, getting indigestion, or sore stomach muscles from EXTEME tension, this is a book for you. Originally published in 1997, the current novel is available in paperback, republished in 2011 by Chicago Review Press.
Always a fan of Mary Stewart since I was a child, I’d never read Rose Cottage until my mother recently bought the book from Bas Bleu and passed it on to me after she’d read it. A wonderful story about a girl stigmatized by her mother’s past indescretions, Rose Cottage is a gentle sweep back in time, living through the mind and eyes of a girl whose gotten on with her life, despite a painful childhood wrought by jealousy and revenge.
The novel takes us to, first, Scotland, then England back right after the conclusion of WWII. With berns and brooks, thrushes, blue bells, and old fashioned roses, this book is actually a gentle mystery that proves at once satisfying, yet discerning.
This isn’t a book for folks looking for excitement. Nor is it a book for those who prefer shallowly written and tersely delivered plot. This is an old-fashioned, and, therefore, pleasant experience for true readers who enjoy the more in-depth pacing and subtleties of purely excellent writing.
Needless to say, I highly recommend this novel, a book which strays from author Mary Stewart’s more well-known genre of “classic romance”, now known as historical fantasy, bringing you a more mainstream modern historical. In my opinion, it’s well worth your time and money if you want a solidly, well-written novel that is written in that most wonderful Mary Stewart style.
4 gold stars. It loses one because this isn’t “great” literature, just a very good novel for a lazy Sunday afternoon.![]()
- Paperback: 240 pages
- Publisher: Chicago Review Press; Rep Una edition (September 1, 2011)
- Language: English
–D. L. Keur, The Deepening World of Books

