The Italy Conspiracy
Author: J.D. Mallinson
Paperback: 210 pages
Publisher: CreateSpace (April 11, 2011)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1456481940
ISBN-13: 978-1456481940
My first thought as I settled down with this book was “I think this book would benefit from another run-through with a red pen.” The first line in the book, which typically sets the tone for the remainder of the reading, included a rather distracting typo. It was the first of a few (but notable) problems with what was otherwise a fair book.
Strengths
The strengths of the author’s writing are apparent where descriptions of a gustatory nature are concerned, or where historical accuracy is important. Also, the picture we’re painted of the beautiful Swiss countryside is positively entrancing. Each time I sat down to read, I invariably got up shortly after to drink some coffee and nibble on something, to satisfy the yearning these passages gave me.
Weaknesses
I love both books and food – this is important in that both figure prominently in the storyline. I’d say they were represented not quite equally: although books were part of the main thrust of the plot, in which stolen books lead to an entirely larger problem that involves state security, more detail is given to the discussion of the food consumed throughout the course of the novel than of the stolen books that are so important to the resolution of the plot.
Another failing is that there is little to differentiate the main character from other players in this book. Everyone’s dialogue is roughly the same, in terms of their cadence, tone and sentence structure. There is little variation throughout the novel in this respect. Also, while the author has a wonderful command of language, the interaction between characters is too formal and awkward and, at times, it’s difficult to follow. Every character speaks as though he or she lives in Victorian England, complete with affectations and airs.
A Little of Both
Had this been a history book or travel journal, it would have hit high points with me. As it was, it read more like just that – a fascinating travel journal of someone who happened to be involved in unraveling a scandalous European crime. It did not, however, seem like a mystery novel.
As a light beach read, this book hits the spot, or as a treat while you’re commuting. However, I probably wouldn’t pick up another in the series unless I felt that the above issues were addressed.
(I received a proof copy of this book for review. My opinion is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the owners or administrators of this site.)